Garage Door Spring Replacement: DIY vs. Professional Cost Comparison

Common Garage Door Opener Problems & Solutions
Greeley Garage Door Opener Troubleshooting: Expert Solutions for Common Issues
June 2, 2025
Automatic Garage Door Installation & Maintenance Guide
Installation and Upkeep Tips for Your First Automatic Garage Door
June 20, 2025
Show all

Garage Door Spring Replacement: DIY vs. Professional Cost Comparison

Replacing garage door springs is a critical maintenance task that ensures smooth operation and safety. But should you tackle it yourself or hire a professional? Explore the costs, risks, and advantages of DIY versus professional garage door spring replacement to make the best choice for your situation.

  1. Why Garage Door Springs Need Replacement

Garage door springs (torsion or extension) bear the weight of the door, making them prone to wear and tear. Signs you need a replacement include:
⚠ Loud snapping noises (a broken spring)
⚠ Door struggles to open or close
⚠ Visible gaps or damage in the spring
⚠ Uneven door movement

Springs typically last 7-12 years, depending on usage and climate.

  1. Types of Garage Door Springs

Torsion Springs
  • Location: Mounted horizontally above the door.
  • Lifespan: 10,000-20,000 cycles (~7-12 years).
  • Cost: $100-$300 per spring (parts only).
Extension Springs
  • Location: Run vertically along the tracks.
  • Lifespan: 5,000-10,000 cycles (~5-7 years).
  • Cost: $20-$50 per spring (parts only).
  1. DIY Garage Door Spring Replacement: Costs & Risks

DIY Costs
DIY Garage Door Spring Replacement: Costs
Pros of DIY Replacement

✅ Lower upfront cost (no labor fees).
✅ Immediate repair if you have the skills.

Cons & Risks of DIY

❌ Extremely dangerous – Springs are under high tension (risk of injury).
❌ Faulty installation might result in damage to the door and opener.
❌ No warranty on parts or labor.

When DIY Might Work

✔ You have experience with garage door systems.
✔ You own proper tools (winding bars, safety gear).
✔ You’re replacing extension springs (lower risk than torsion).

  1. Professional Garage Door Spring Replacement: Costs & Benefits

Professional Service Costs

Professional Garage Door Spring Replacement

Why Hire a Pro?

✅ Safety first – Trained technicians handle high-tension springs.
✅ Correct installation – Ensures balanced door operation.
✅ Warranty coverage – Most pros offer 1-2 years on parts/labor.
✅ Time-saving – Done in 1-2 hours vs. DIY trial and error.

When to Call a Professional

✔ You’re replacing torsion springs (high-risk job).
✔ You lack tools or mechanical experience.
✔ The door is either heavy or equipped with high-lift spring mechanisms

  1. Key Factors Affecting Replacement Cost

  1. Spring Type – Torsion springs cost more than extension.
  2. Door Weight – Heavier doors need stronger (pricier) springs.
  3. Single vs. Dual Springs – Two springs cost more but improve longevity.
  4. Labor Rates – Vary by location (urban areas = higher costs).
  1. Safety Warning: Why DIY Spring Replacement Is Risky

Garage door springs are under extreme tension (200+ lbs of force). A mishap can cause:
🔴 Severe injuries (broken bones, cuts, eye damage).
🔴 Door collapse (if improperly installed).
🔴 Voided homeowner’s insurance (if unlicensed work causes damage).

Never attempt torsion spring replacement without proper training!

  1. Final Verdict: DIY or Hire a Pro?

torsion springs

Recommendation:

💡 For torsion springs → Always hire a pro.
💡 For extension springs → DIY only if skilled.

  1. Need Spring Replacement? Call the Pros!

Don’t risk injury or improper installation—schedule professional garage door spring replacement today!

📞 Call Us for Fast, Safe Service – (970) 673-0951
🛠️ Licensed & Insured Technicians